Carson's Reviews

$15.00
ISBN-13: 9780452297647
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Plume, 12/2011

Natasha Solomons's The House at Tyneford tells in flowery tones a dynastic tale of romance and grief in war-torn Britain.  Set in 1938, the Viennese heroine, Elise Landau is separated from her close-knit family by the impounding peril of war.  To Elise, her Jewish identity means little more than a bohemian lifestyle, but her parents Julian and Anna know their unwed daughter must be sent away from Austria for her protection.

Young Elise is taken in by a stately manor in England, her safety bartered for her demotion from respectable Fraulein to mere chambermaid.  Elise's shortcomings as a servant are intensified by her homesickness for her sister and parents, the latter of whom she receives little news.  When Mr. Rivers's devilish son Kit returns from Cambridge, Elise has a new distraction, but hardly a reprieve from heartache.

 The simple story is adorned with visceral beauty, the descriptions of the English countryside are adundant with "swallows zooming" and "snapdragons dyed vermillion pink in the setting sun."  Elise's bildungsroman gradually slides into the account of a survivor, a body count of her loved ones rising.  Her world explodes by the blasts of warfare, ruthlessly stripped to its bones, all in the name of patriotic necessity.  Enmeshed in Elise's seismic uncertainties is her pursuit of self and identity.  She is neither maid, nor proper English woman.  She is not Kit's wife, nor is she his mistress.  Her sense of residence in limbo is felt by both Elise and the reader throughout the story.  It is only in the end,when it seesms that nothing of Elise's old or new life remains, does she finally find home in the most unexpected of places.


$16.00
ISBN-13: 9780143120582
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Penguin (Non-Classics), 12/2011

In this parenting memoir, tigress mother Amy Chua documents her daughters' upbringing at the intersection of East and West. Chua, a Yale law professor and daughter of Chinese emigres, wholly credits her strict, uncompromising parents with her life's success. When her daughters are born, she and her husband Jed (“a white boy,” Chua's parents lamented) make a decision to raise Sophia and Lulu under the restrictions of Chinese parenting. The girls were not only expected to get top grades, they are pressured to achieve musically under the hawk-eyed surveillance.

Although readers of American parentage may balk at Chua's “tough love” tactics, the author repeatedly assures readers that her tactics are the norm in China. Though at times she borders on mass generalizations on East versus West, e.g. “American parents place too much emphasis on creativity and self-esteem,” and “Chinese kids end up respecting their parents far more than Westerners do.” Chua's daughters may corroborate her theories. At 13, Sophia performed at Carnegie Hall, and Lulu auditioned for Julliard's pre-college program. These accomplishments, however, do not come without cost. Told in a candid and clear voice, Battle Hymn is strongest when it concedes to self-reflection. Chua is brave for inviting the reader along on her blistering recollection of parenthood from hope and expectation to love and acceptance.